"Beware the implications for nurses of assisted dying law"
While imminent changes to the law are unlikely, the issue of assisted dying is not going to go away
Public and professional reaction to the recent report from the Commission on Assisted Dying has been predictably emotive. Whatever your opinion of the findings, the authors are to be commended for the thoroughness with which they addressed the issues, and the humanity that comes through their arguments for revised legislation.
Unfortunately, this can lull the unwary into acceptance of what seems on paper to be perfectly reasonable - namely to allow terminally ill people of sound mind the option of active help to commit suicide.
The report is clear that the primary responsibility for consulting, drug prescription, assistance at the bedside and follow-up support lies with doctors. There is a naivety here that fails to acknowledge nurses’ role in supporting patients and families, and whether they are required to be present when the intervention takes place.
The authors expect that, should legislation be forthcoming, most assisted suicide will be in the home, which puts district and community palliative care nurses at the forefront of this proposal.
A colleague and I recently taught a mixed group of health professionals and gave them a questionnaire that presumed that such legislation was in place. We asked about the place of the suicide, who would attend, the licensing and inspection of premises other than the home, conflict with codes of conduct, clinical protocols and procedures, education and whether they would consider taking part.
Few had even considered that assisted suicide might take place outside the home, and many felt some other health professional should be there as a safeguard.
No one wanted to be part of it, while acknowledging that no conscience clause exists. No one had thought about the need for procedures and protocols and fears were voiced about the legal ramifications.
The session was a success because the participants had been confronted with a potential future reality, which none had considered.
The report mentions implications for nurses once. It states: “Professional bodies, including the General Medical Council and the Nursing and Midwifery Council would need to develop codes of practice to guide appropriate professional conduct and specify appropriate training and levels of experience for professionals who take a role in assisted dying.”
This report is unlikely to lead to legislation. But, make no mistake, while no self-respecting government could be seen to endorse the proposals - particularly in the wake of scandals around care of older people - this issue will not go away.
Nurses must remain open minded, well informed and ready to respond with skill and humanity to the difficult conversations that accompany requests for help to die. We do know where support is available such requests often recede, which is a powerful argument for better end-of-life services.
Robert Becker is Macmillan senior lecturer in palliative care, Staffordshire University and Severn Hospice, Shropshire
Keep up to date
Do you want to be kept informed of new articles like this or on a wide range of specialist subjects? If you register with nursingtimes.net you can sign up for regular newsletters on the subjects that interest you, so you don’t miss the news and practice information that’s relevant to you. It’s quick and easy – just click here.
The Commission on Assisted Dying (2012) London: Demos.