By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

Your browser seems to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser.


Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.


Book club: your reviews

All posts from: October 2011

Assessing Evidence to improve Population Health and Wellbeing

31 October, 2011 Posted by: -

  • Title: Assessing Evidence to improve Population Health and Wellbeing (Transforming Public Health Practice)
  • Author: Carmen Aceijas
  • Publisher: Learning Matters Ltd.
  • Reviewer: Paul Watson, School Nurse, Norfolk Community Health and Care (NCH+C).


What was it like?

This is one book written as part of a larger series of “Transforming Public Health Practice” to support practitioners undertaking a Masters in public health, although I believe that any student looking at this area would find this particular resource invaluable. This book considers the main concepts, issues and methodologies of the second core competence of the Public Health Skills and Career Framework: ‘Assessment of evidence of the effectiveness of interventions, programmes and services


to improve population health and wellbeing’. I was very impressed that the areas covered include the theoretical definition of evidence and its use in public health, the role of critical appraisal methods and tools in evidence assessment and how Effectiveness, Efficiency and Quality inform evidence. I wish I’d had such a clear and succinct tool in my arsenal, not only when completing my Public Health Degree but also my PGCE.

What were the highlights?

This book has many case studies and activities to help link theory and practice and prompt personal reflection in any practitioner or reader. I don’t believe that this is a book designed for bed time reading (I tried it, not good for me!), what it is though, in my opinion, is a very well thought out and executed tool designed exactly to do “what it says on the tin!”, allowing the user to dip in and out of the book as required to get answers to questions or to guide them in a new direction.

Strengths and weaknesses?

I felt that the specific design to the public health framework and the detailed description of how to use and access the information, will make this book a  tool that all Public Health Students, Practitioners and Practice Teachers should have access to. I have not reviewed the other titles but hope that they are as equally impressive as I believe that this would then provide a complete resource to guide the user to successful qualifications/ Public Health delivery. This is a nice looking book that has kept itself smaller and useable by being part of a series and I was impressed that there is an “e-reader” version feeling that the opportunity to have all of the series on a device at the same time would be a great aid to any reader.

Who should read it?

I would be recommending this as essential reading to any public health student but also and possibly more importantly I would advise any senior practitioner or practice teacher with a student to get hold of a copy.



Comments (2)

Bread, Jam and a Borrowed Pram: A nurse’s story from the streets

14 October, 2011 Posted by: -

  • Title: Bread, Jam and a Borrowed Pram: A nurse’s story from the streets
  • Author: Dot May Dunn
  • Publisher: Orion Books, 2011
  • Reviewer: Jenni Middleton, Editor, Nursing Times, EMAP

What was it like?

Health visitors could probably moonlight quite easily as authors. Their ability to enter people’s homes and experience first hand their patients’ lives probably gives them enough anecdotes to fill up 100 novels. Dot May Dunn, a former nurse with 50 years’ experience in the NHS, has so far produced two. Bread, Jam and a Borrowed Pram follows the success of her first novel Twelve Babies on a Bike, which was a Sunday Times Top 10 Bestseller. Her most recent novel tells the story of Dot, a newly qualified health visitor in 1958, who works in an inner city clinic.

Narrated from Dot’s perspective, we feel the trials and tribulations first hand of heading alone to houses that are unwelcoming either because of their inhabitants, their cleanliness or of the odours they emit. Her non-judgemental approach to her service user group exposes us to the real kindness that existed as well as the extreme poverty during this period, and the storytelling has a real vintage feel to it, you are exported back in time with every turn of the page. It also reveals just how much entrepreneurial spirit health visitors had to exhibit in the 1950s in order to look after their patients.

There is a vast parade of characters, all colourfully created to show the difficulties of surviving anything from losing a job to coping without running water in your home. The heartbreak of child death, a grieving widow suffering with a mental illness, alcoholism and women entering prostitution to make ends meet is dealt with sensitively, but never over-dramatised. The stories of the cast list of the book are sometimes sad, sometimes funny, but always interesting.

What were the highlights?

For all the austerity of the time, it does not paint too bleak a picture of life, and Dot’s love of her job is always evident, even when she’s handling a busy clinic, failing to help a family to her satisfaction or becoming frustrated by the human condition. Her inspirational nature really shines through and would, I think, warm the heart of anyone working in nursing today. She is a nurse, through and through.

Strengths and weaknesses?

The funny stories are used to punctuate some of the tales of hardship but are not lavished too heavily on the book so that it loses some of its accuracy in terms of reportage. The vastness of the caseload has clearly been edited for this diary-style account of Dot’s day, but still some of the characters are difficult to connect with because it is such a vast cast list.

Who should read it?

A brilliant book for current health visitors who want to compare their caseloads and careers with those who trod the pavements in the 1950s. But I suspect that anyone who was a health visitor in the late ‘50s and early ‘60s would enjoy Bread, Jam and a Borrowed Pram the most for its walk down memory lane.




Multiple opportunities

Competitive Salary plus "golden hello" + relocation package

Community Nurse

£15 - 22 per hour

Registered Nurse

£15 - 22 per hour