Student nurses are often accused of being too academic and lacking caring values, but a study found new students have strong values and caring attitudes
In this article…
- History of training and the move to higher education colleges
- Current perception of nursing in the media
- Why students at one university chose to become nurses
Paula Crick is head of the School of Health; Louise Perkinton and Fiona Davies are senior lecturers; all at the University of Derby.
Crick P et al (2014) Why do student nurses want to be nurses? Nursing Times; 110: 5, 12-15.
Nursing became an all graduate entry profession in September 2013; this move and the publication of the Francis report have brought the debate around nurse education and nurses’ capacity to care into sharper focus. There is much debate over what makes a good nurse and whether graduate nurses lack care and compassion.
Aim and method
We asked a cohort of pre-registration student nurses on the first day of their course about their motivations to join the profession, what being a nurse meant to them and which aspects of nursing they valued most.
The demographics of the degree student group were similar to those of diploma students. Reasons cited for entering the profession and views on the nurse’s role showed that students’ motivations and perceptions focused on nursing as a caring rather than a technical profession.
The characteristics of the degree students, their strong motivation to care and perception of nursing in altruistic terms contradict the media image of student nurses as being primarily academically, technically and career driven.
- This article has been double-blind peer reviewed
- Figures and tables can be seen in the attached print-friendly PDF file of the complete article in the ‘Files’ section of this page
5 key points
- Nursing became an all graduate entry profession in September 2013
- Questions have been raised over whether current student nurses lack caring qualities and enter the profession for the wrong reasons
- Nursing continues to attract a wide age range, and students with different levels of academic achievement
- Although student nurses tend to start their course with positive attitudes, these can be lost over time
- Value-based recruitment of student nurses is essential to select nurses with the right qualities to care
Nursing has traditionally been seen as a vocational career, with caring at its core (Williams et al, 2009). However, this view is being threatened by an increased focus on the issue of nurses not demonstrating adequate levels of care, compassion and dignity.
To tackle this, recruitment of student nurses with the right qualities is under the spotlight. Karoz (2005) highlighted the importance of students having appropriate caring values and behaviours, while Fry and Johnstone (2008) believed that only people with the knowledge, skills and commitment to practise nursing in a clinically, culturally and ethically competent way should enter the profession.
Nursing becoming an all graduate entry profession in 2013 and publication of the Francis report (2013) have both contributed to an increased focus on nurses’ values and capacity to care and on nurse education. Negative headlines such as “Nurses told, ‘you’re not too posh to wash a patient’: minister orders student nurses back to basics to improve compassion in NHS” (Chapman and Martin, 2013) suggest a lack of caring is in some way the fault of student nurses and nurse education. Other media stories have claimed nurses are more interested in technical and advanced clinical skills than in essential care (Brodell, 2009), and point to changes within the health system, such as more paperwork and a lack of qualified staff, leading to nurses having too little time to care (Martin, 2012).
Concerns that nurses are “too posh to wash” (Hall, 2004), and that a higher academic entry level would lead to nurses being less caring (Adams and Smith, 2012) have been voiced since nursing programmes moved to higher education institutions. The suggestion is that nurses with higher educational qualifications are less interested in providing essential care.
To investigate these claims, we explored the characteristics of a degree cohort of student nurses to find out what motivated them to join the profession, what being a nurse meant to them, and the aspects of nursing they valued most.
Degree-level pre-registration nurse education has been available in the UK since 1960 (Ring, 2002), but only a few people undertook the degree until nurse education moved into higher education between 1989 and 1995. Most graduate nurses remain in clinical areas, especially community and intensive care, for at least 10 years after qualifying (Ring, 2002), which does not reflect the view that graduate nurses are reluctant to engage in hands-on care. More recently, the Willis Commission found no major shortcomings in nurse education that directly cause poor practice or the perceived decline in standards of care, nor did it find any evidence that degree-level training had a negative effect on patient care (Willis, 2012).
Over recent months, there has also been a focus on how student nurses are recruited to pre-registration programmes, with questions over whether candidates have the right values to care, and whether they should gain significant caring experience before starting their course.
Many universities have demonstrated the robustness of their selection processes, making clear they use values-based criteria and ensure candidates have a good understanding of what nursing is including, for many, prior experience of caring. However, in March 2013, health secretary Jeremy Hunt, said potential student nurses should complete up to a year in a caring role before starting the three-year degree. Health Education England, in collaboration with the NHS, has set up pre-registration nursing experience pilot schemes in six local education and training boards (LETBs) across England.
This study was devised to ascertain the qualities and values that student nurses already hold when they start their degree. A further study will examine how these qualities and values develop and change over the three years of the programme.
The cohort consisted of 115 student nurses at the University of Derby, who were asked to complete a questionnaire on their first day at university in September 2012; this asked for demographic data and qualitative information about their reasons for entering the profession and their understanding of the role of nurses. The questionnaire included open and closed questions and was developed as an efficient and quick way to collect the data; 112 students completed and returned it.
The demographic data of the study group was compared with data from a group of 133 diploma students from September 2008.
The questionnaire was first given to a pilot group, and feedback did not identify any significant problems with reliability; validity of the questionnaire was established as the information gathered met the requirements of the study.
Students received an information sheet and signed a consent form. Names were not included but each participant was given a number so that future questionnaires could be linked to this one.
The questionnaire revealed that the demographics of the study group were similar to those of the diploma cohort. The majority were female (83%), the average age was 28, and 49% were the first in their family to come into higher education (Table 1).
In terms of academic background, 45% of the study group had completed an access course, 32% had A-levels and 21% already held a diploma or degree (Figs 1 and 2). With regard to caring experience, 86% had prior experience of caring; the remaining 14% did not offer any comment on their caring experience. Caring experience fell into four categories: paid work as a healthcare assistant or support worker (64%); volunteering within a care setting (17%); a placement arranged by school or college (12%); and caring for family members (7%).
Students were asked if nursing was their first choice of career. Given the age range of the cohort, it was expected that a reasonable number would have already had a different career and 32% did.
All students answered the question: “Why did you decide to come into nursing?” The most frequently used words in the responses were the desire to “help” (26%) or “care” (25%), to forward their “career” (23%), or their “passion” (9%) for the profession. We identified four themes in their decisions to enter the profession; many cited more than one.
- Reasons that were intrinsically motivated and altruistic in nature, for example “what I always wanted”, “in my nature”, “I’m a caring person”, “want to make a difference”, “I want to do something worthwhile”. This theme occurred in 60% of responses.
- Reasons that came from positive experiences of nursing or caring, including personal experience as a service user or patient, experience of caring for family members or witnessing a relative’s care. This theme was evident in 21% of responses.
- Direct experience of the nursing profession from working with nurses or having family members who are nurses. This was evident in 17% of responses.
- The desire to gain a professional qualification, progress in their career or change their career, which was evident in 16% of responses.
- A minority (4%) said their decision was related to a poor experience of nursing or healthcare, and their determination to do it better.
The final question asked what participants felt the role of a nurse was; this reveals their view of nursing built from experience, background research and media influence. The most common responses included the nurse cares (81% of responses), helps (32%) and supports (24%) the patient or service user, with 19% believing the nurse’s role is to give the best possible care. Communication was mentioned in 44% of responses including aspects such as listening, understanding, trust and empathy, with 7% using the word compassion, and 7% seeing nurses as patients’ advocates. Just 11% mentioned the nurse’s role in curing, healing or giving treatment.
The results of this study show that entrants to a nursing degree programme at the University of Derby have similar demographic characteristics to those of past advanced diploma cohorts.
It appears that the profession continues to attract a wide age range and students with different levels of academic achievement. A good proportion (in this case, almost half) come from access courses and some (a fifth in this cohort) already hold a diploma or first degree. Though not a driver for the study, it is reassuring that there is still evidence of “widening participation” in higher education as this shows the change in academic requirements has not deterred students coming from the access route, older students or those who are the first in their family to come into higher education.
The majority of the study cohort came into the profession with caring experience; almost two-thirds had worked as a paid healthcare assistant or support worker. The values-based selection process at Derby, which involves service users, carers and clinicians as well as academic staff, requires candidates to show not only qualities of care and compassion, but also evidence of an understanding of healthcare. The government call for all student nurses to have up to a year’s care experience is therefore already being fulfilled for the majority of student nurses. The current pilot programmes offering pre-registration degree work experience may be of value to applicants who do not have significant healthcare or support work experience. It will be interesting to see the outcomes of these pilot schemes in terms of what they contribute to student nurse development.
It is apparent from the students’ reasons for entering the profession that most would be considered to have the caring and compassionate qualities expected of a nurse (Box 1).
Participants’ motivations to become nurses were largely vocational; the primary motivator for these student nurses to enter the profession was given as a desire to care for others. Many described their motivation as coming from having experienced or witnessed positive examples of nursing care, with some influenced by working alongside nurses, or having a nurse in the family. It is heartening that within a media climate that seems to consistently highlight poor care and lack of compassion, the vast majority of new student nurses have been influenced by good care and positive role models. Indeed, only a small percentage were influenced by an experience of poor care.
Some students stated they wanted to progress or change their career. As many are older students, career change and progression was an inevitable factor. The focus on “care” was evident in this group’s account of what they saw the role of a nurse to be; examples are presented in Box 2.
The scope of definitions offered appears rather narrow, focusing on care, support and communication, with little mention of the medical, technical and administrative parts of the nurse role. This could be due to recent media stories accusing nurses of not caring, or not having time to care because of administrative and technical tasks. This perception of care being at the core of nursing, and being the predominant motivator for individuals to enter the profession has been found in other studies. O’Brien et al (2008) also acknowledged the role of the media in shaping perceptions of what nursing is. It could be argued that these views are idealised, but the consistency of this finding suggests that it is part of student nurses’ vocation, despite changes to the nursing role over recent years.
This cohort of student nurses entered the profession with a strong desire to care and to make a positive difference to people’s lives.
The move to all-graduate entry has not resulted in fewer mature students entering the profession, and it is still attracting those with access qualifications and those who are the first in their family to come into higher education. This challenges current media images of graduate nurses as academically and career focused and “too posh to wash”.
Hopefully, students from this cohort will maintain their motivation, positive views and beliefs throughout their course and career. Smith (1992) identified a “caring trajectory” in which students began a nursing course idealistic and eager to care for patients but later became disillusioned, cynical and preoccupied with getting through their studies. Further study is planned to find whether student nurses’ values, beliefs and perceptions of nursing change throughout the three years of their degree programme.
Adams S, Smith R (2012) Nurses “are losing their sense of compassion”. The Telegraph; 9 January.
Brodell EB (2009) Views of Student Nurses on Caring and Technology in Nursing. PhD thesis. Grand Forks ND: University of North Dakota.
Chapman J, Martin D (2013) Nurses told, “you’re not too posh to wash a patient”: Minister orders student nurses back to basics to improve compassion in NHS. Mail Online; 25 March.
Francis R (2013) Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. London: Stationery Office.
Fry ST, Johnstone MJ (2008) Ethics in Nursing Practice: a Guide to Ethical Decision Making. Chichester: Blackwell.
Hall C (2004) Young nurses “too posh to wash”. The Telegraph; 11 May.
Karoz S (2005) Turkish nursing students’ perception of caring. Nurse Education Today; 25: 31-40.
Martin D (2012) Nurses must be told to “talk to patients”: PM’s intervention is a damning indictment of care on our hospital wards. Mail Online; 6 January.
O’Brien F et al (2008) Impressions of nursing before exposure to the field. Journal of Clinical Nursing; 17: 1843-1850.
Ring N (2002) A personal and historical investigation of the career trends of UK graduate nurses qualifying between 1970 and 1989. Journal of Advanced Nursing; 40: 2, 199-209.
Smith P (1992) The Emotional Labour of Nursing. Macmillan: Basingstoke.
Williams G et al (2009) Do nurses really care? Confirming the stereotype with a case controlled study. British Journal of Nursing; 18, 162-165.
Willis P (2012) Quality with Compassion: the Future of Nursing Education. Report of the Willis Commission on Nursing Education. London: Royal College of Nursing.