The new health checks must not be allowed to increase inequalities
The vascular screening programme aims to improve public health but PCTs and GPs must ensure it does not widen the health inequality gap, warns Gladys Xavier
From April 2009–2010, the NHS is being asked to implement a risk assessment and management programme for people in England aged 40–74, to identify those at risk of developing vascular disease. One vital question, however, is whether such a programme will actually increase – rather than reduce – health inequalities.
The Department of Health has asked PCTs to work through the service provision, workforce and prescribing implications of introducing vascular checks before taking decisions about the rate at which they plan to roll out the programme.
It is estimated that the screening programme could eventually prevent at least 9,500 heart attacks and strokes each year (of which 2,000 would be fatal). It could also prevent at least 4,000 people a year from developing diabetes and enable the earlier detection of at least 25,000 cases of diabetes or kidney disease (Department of Health, 2008a).
Of all the options considered, the preference was for starting screening at the age of 40, with checks every five years. The average cost for a basic vascular check is estimated at £23.70 (DH, 2008b). There are also the costs of knock-on tests if a patient has high blood pressure, is diagnosed with diabetes or has high fasting blood glucose.
The DH has developed a toolkit, which enables PCTs to use local prevalence rates to estimate local demand for interventions following the checks. This will mean extra capacity to deliver smoking cessation, and obesity interventions will also need to be increased.
For an average GP practice of three GPs, it is estimated this is equivalent to 330 new invitations and 250 new attendances per year for screening, of which 125 will be additional work. However, while detailed national modelling has been carried out, the proportion of the population found to be at high vascular risk is likely to vary greatly at local level, and will be high in deprived areas and among black and minority ethnic patients.
It would be useful for PCTs to have an estimate of the likely proportion of the population with a greater than 20% cardiovascular disease risk, and the costs involved, with a facility to provide such estimates at practice level.
However, this programme has the potential to increase or reduce health inequalities, depending on how it is implemented, and PCTs and GP practices should be aware of this danger.
A campaign to raise public awareness through a range of media should be carried out before the programme is launched to provide ‘advance notification’. For example, this could be done by leaflet drops.
Personalised GP-signed mailed invitations could be used as a major recruitment method, but a fairly low uptake of 30–40% should be expected, and arrangements for a follow-up letter and telephone call should be put in place beforehand.
Opportunistic screening of patients over 75 should be considered – the vascular checks programme has a cut-off at the age of 74, and most strokes occur in people over 75. To prevent stroke, it is important to ensure that hypertension is controlled in this age group.
Additional funding and staff resources should be allocated from the outset to reduce ethnic and socioeconomic variations in uptake. Other providers such as pharmacists could be commissioned and used to further increase uptake.
However, all data should be incorporated into GP computer systems to monitor outcome and identify non-attenders. Comparative evaluations of the uptake after different interventions, such as those published for cancer screening, should be carried out.
These measures are vital to ensure that this programme does not have the reverse effect and serve to widen health inequalities further.
Gladys Xavier is deputy director of public health, NHS Redbridge
Department of Health (2008a) Putting Prevention First. Vascular Checks: Risk Assessment and Management. London: DH.
Department of Health(2008b) Economic Modelling for Vascular Checks. London: DH.