Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Close

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

OPINION

Roger Kline: 'Denying race bias exists in the NHS is damaging to everyone'

  • 10 Comments

In every aspect of NHS employment and in some aspects of patient services, evidence of racism is common, says Roger Kline

Fifty years ago women were less likely to be appointed to senior NHS jobs than men. It was deemed perfectly acceptable to ask women at interview if they planned to have children and, if so, to not employ or promote them. Women were paid less and got smaller bonus payments for doing the same job. It wasn’t seen as discrimination; women just weren’t as “good” as men.

All sorts of explanations were given why such discrimination was appropriate or wasn’t really discrimination at all. We were told employers should appoint and pay people on merit, not on gender. It just so happened men were better.

We all hold prejudices. They come from families, friends, schools, communities and the media. When prejudices turn into discrimination, it leads to unfair treatment.

Fifty years ago NHS discrimination against women, black and minority ethnic and Irish nurses, doctors and cleaners was common, although many people denied it existed or justified it.

Today, women become senior managers, and BME and Irish doctors can become medical directors and chief nurses (although not very often), not least because many practices common 50 years ago are unlawful now. However, discrimination in the NHS continues, albeit less openly.

The evidence of such subtle, unconscious NHS discrimination is overwhelming. The Discrimination by Appointment report by social enterprise Public World, for example, showed that shortlisted white applicants were nearly twice as likely to be appointed as shortlisted BME staff. Presumably, all shortlisted candidates met the person specification, so we need to know what happened, since this result suggests ethnicity influenced appointment decisions. Research shows similar patterns in promotion, discipline and grading.

‘All that is sought is a level playing field that allows those with the best potential to be appointed and treats all staff fairly irrespective of their skin colour - or indeed their gender, sexuality, disability or religion’

In every aspect of NHS employment and in some aspects of patient services, evidence of racism is common. Yet, on the last two occasions I set out the evidence in Nursing Times, I have been astonished at the responses that deny the existence of race discrimination or question the motives of those pointing to the evidence.

If we were discussing patient safety, we would say let’s look at the data, listen to staff and patients and act on the evidence. When presented with uncomfortable or unexpected information, it is right to question it but, when it overwhelmingly suggests a problem, we need to act.

Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust responded to the indications that the hospital was failing with denial. Many people deny climate change is man-made despite the evidence. We should be wary of treating evidence of race discrimination similarly.
I don’t argue - and I don’t know anyone who does - that staff should be selected for jobs or not disciplined because they are in a BME group. All that is sought is a level playing field that allows those with the best potential to be appointed and treats all staff fairly irrespective of their skin colour - or indeed their gender, sexuality, disability or religion.

Staff who deny race discrimination exists in the NHS should ask themselves if they could recognise unconscious bias towards colleagues or patients. In patient safety, we start with the data, listen, then act. We should take the same approach with racial discrimination. This is not only because it matters to staff - research at Aston Business School reported a correlation between such adverse treatment and the patient experience.

Nurses who deny that racism exists in the NHS do themselves, their colleagues and patients a disservice. We need to talk about it.

Roger Kline is research fellow at Middlesex University and an associate consultant with Public World

  • 10 Comments

Readers' comments (10)

  • Brendan Martin

    Readers might like to know how to download Public World's free report, Discrimination by Appointment, mentioned in this article. It is available here:
    http://bit.ly/16G7VZw

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Brendan Martin

    Readers might like to know how to download Public World's free report, Discrimination by Appointment, mentioned in this article. It is available here:
    http://bit.ly/16G7VZw

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well said Roger.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Thanks for starting to talk about it Roger. I'm afraid that racial discrimination is widely practised in the NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Thank you Roger.
    "We all hold prejudices." - I think maybe that's the bit people are afraid of.

    How many times do you hear people say "I'm not racist, but..." when what they really mean is "I wouldn't want you to think I'm racist, but ... (and obviously because I'm not racist my views have more value) ..."

    The truth is we ALL hold prejudices - we're ALL human.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Really appreciate this discussion happening. I agree we all hold prejudices, blind spots and cultural comfort blankets, shame is what usually keeps all this in place and a lack of opportunity to safe examinations of them.
    I hope this changes

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nero and Rome spring to mind here.

    You're probably right: race bias may well exist in the NHS, but I think we both know that equal opps will be so, so low down on the agenda in a post Francis NHS - as the low number of participants in this 'hot seat' discussion attests - that whilst your little pamphlet made 10 minutes interesting reading on a cold train ride into town, it was a little too nuance for me - I'd read it all before.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anonymous | 19-Nov-2013 2:18 am

    Yes. A lot of people will continue to ignore the issue and might even excuse themselves from any responsibility, as you have. That is one of the main reasons that race bias continues to exist.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We need to realise that racism also exists against British born whites too. That is much harder to protest, as if you do, you are being 'racist'. I have been a 'victim' of this, also been discriminated against because I have no children. Have I protested, no because it's more than my jobs worth.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am glad someone is saying this.Thank you.
    Discrimination exists in work places everywhere.This is a CULTURE that should stop.Surprisingly,Sir.Francis did not mention how to tackle 'culture'.What's the way forward?















    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.