Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

NIHR Signal

Check for nasogastric tube position is cost effective and prevents deaths

  • Comment

Inappropriately placed nasogastric tubes can cause serious harm to patients. This summary of an NIHR-funded study includes an online self-assessment to test your understanding of the research


Nasogastric tubes are used to deliver liquids directly to the stomach. However, tubes can be misplaced, often into the lungs, which can have serious consequences.  Death or lung damage from misplaced NG tubes is avoidable and considered a ‘never event’ in the NHS, so the final position of NG tubes must be checked.  

NHS guidance states that pH testing should be the first choice to detect correct placement, followed by X-ray if necessary, and new research confirms this.  A modelling study compared the two approaches with direct trade-offs between cost and effectiveness.  It confirmed that, for adults who need an NG tube for a short time, pH testing was the best initial approach, followed by X-ray confirmation if pH testing was unsuccessful. pH testing was four times less expensive than X-ray confirmation and, when used in sequence, both were cost-effective uses of NHS resources.

A resource to support providers is available from NHS Improvement. This is important if the harm from these events is to be reduced to zero.

Expert commentary

Carolyn Best, nutrition nurse specialist, Royal Hampshire County Hospital, Winchester

A nasogastric tube is passed through the nasal passage via the oesophagus into the stomach to empty the stomach contents or administer feed, medicines or fluid. It is one of the most common routes for enteral nutrition support in hospitals within the UK. However, insertion can be difficult, so checking the position of the tip of the tube is vital. 

In the past we were taught the ‘whoosh test’, using air and a stethoscope to check the tube position but this method has been shown to be grossly inaccurate. 

X-ray confirmation, while considered the gold standard, is expensive and relies on correct interpretation of the image by a doctor, which may result in a delay in feeding. 

X-ray cannot be used as means of monitoring the tube position, and the use of pH indicator strips is – as this study highlights – a more cost-effective method as it can be used repeatedly at the bedside.

Implications for practice

  • Nasogastric tube position should be checked immediately after placement, before starting a feed, after vomiting/coughing and observing decreased oxygen saturation, if the tube is accidentally dislodged or if the patient complains of discomfort
  • Misplaced NG tubes can lead to many complications including aspiration pneumonia, pneumothorax and death
  • The old ‘whoosh test’ is inaccurate and has been replaced by pH testing (with strips suitable for testing human aspirate) and chest X-ray. pH testing is cheaper than X-ray and can be done at the bedside, but may be less accurate; however, X-rays only confirm tube position at the time taken, so pH testing is the best way to check tube placement on an ongoing basis
  • pH tests must be undertaken by trained staff who know when to refer a patient for X-ray. X-rays must be interpreted by a competent professional trained to read them.
  • pH test results can be affected by medicines such as proton pump inhibitors or H2 receptor antagonists; intake of milk can neutralise the acid
  • This study confirms current NHS guidance – pH testing as first-line intervention, with X-ray if needed

NIHR Dissemination Centre: right evidence, better decisions

The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Dissemination Centre aims to put good evidence at the heart of decision making in health and social care. NIHR Signals are summaries of the most relevant and important research, published on the Discover PortalSign up for NIHR Signals tailored to your area of interest and keep up with the latest research by following @NIHR_DC on Twitter. Click here for more information

  • This article includes commentary from an independent expert that does not necessarily reflect the views of the NHS, the NIHR or the Department of Health.

Test your research awareness

To check your understanding of the research methodology in the NIHR Signal summarised above, take a quick self-assessment by clicking here

  • Comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.

Related Jobs