Vocal cord dysfunction is often mistaken for asthma. Increasing staff awareness of the condition is essential to effective diagnosis and treatment
In this article…
- An overview of vocal cord dysfunction (VCD), including potential causes
- Signs and symptoms of VCD and how to diagnose it
- How to treat VCD using speech and language therapy
- Staff knowledge and awareness of VCD
Jemma Haines is principal respiratoryspeech and language therapist, Airways Clinic Services, Lancashire Teaching Hospitals Foundation Trust.
Haines J (2011) Diagnosing and treating vocal cord dysfunction. Nursing Times; 107: 42, 18-20.
Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) is a respiratorydisease in which the vocal cords close during breathing. It is often associated with acute signs and symptoms of upper airway obstruction, and is commonly mistaken for asthma. A lack of knowledge of the condition and limited research can make VCD hard to manage.
This article discusses the causes and signs and symptoms of VCD, and how to diagnose and treat the condition. It also explores staff awareness of VCD, and how specialist multidisciplinary clinics dedicated to treating the condition can improve care in complex breathless management.
Keywords: Vocal cord dysfunction/Asthma/respiratory/Speech and language therapy
- This article has been double-blind peer reviewed
- Figures and tables can be seen in the attached print-friendly PDF file of the complete article
5 key points
- Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) is the abnormal closure of the vocal cords during breathing, most commonly during inspiration
- Symptoms are often misdiagnosed as asthma, meaning some patients suffer unnecessary treatment morbidity
- There is poor awareness and understanding on how to best manage VCD due to a lack of robust prospective research
- Diagnosis is typically based on case history and laryngoscopy, but pulmonary function tests, such as spirometry, can add further support
- Patients who have limited, inconsistent or unexpected relief from bronchodilators may have VCD rather than asthma
Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) is a respiratory condition characterised by the paradoxical closure of the vocal cords. In normal respiration, the vocal cords remain open during inspiration and close slightly during expiration; with VCD however, they close when breathing in and out, making it harder to get air into the lungs (Fig 1) (American Thoracic Society, 2009). This can result in wheezing and shortness of breath during the respiratory cycle (Newman and Dubester, 1994).
VCD is often associated with acute signs and symptoms of upper airway obstruction, chronic cough, voice disturbance, and laryngeal hypersensitivity. Many patients with VCD are wrongly diagnosed with respiratory disorders – usually asthma – and can suffer morbidity from unnecessary medical treatment.
The condition can also coexist with other diseases affecting the upper airway, including asthma, rhinitis and gastro-oesophageal reflux, making accurate management challenging. VCD is an important differential diagnosis in asthma and complex breathlessness management. It is becoming more frequently recognised and diagnosed, but prospective studies into differential diagnosis and optimal treatment are limited (Morris et al, 2006).
This article provides an overview of VCD. It aims to increase awareness and understanding of the condition for respiratory nurses, and help general nurses to feel confident about considering VCD as part of the diagnostic pathway.
What causes VCD?
Due to poor prospective research, the true aetiology and pathogenesis of VCD remains uncertain, and there is poor understanding of true epidemiological data.
The overall incidence of VCD is not well defined but this could be due to a lack of agreed consensus and poor awareness of consideration of VCD as a diagnosis. Additionally, terminology relating to the condition is not uniform across professional fields. In recent years, VCD has become the most frequently used term, but the condition is also known as paradoxical vocal cord motion syndrome, irritable larynx syndrome and hysterical croup.
A number of causes have been proposed for VCD, including psychological factors, upper airway sensitivity, laryngeal irritants, gastroesophageal reflux disease and rhinitis, but the cause largely remains unknown (Carding, 2000). Historically, there has been a strong emphasis on psychological factors but organic causes have also been reported more recently. Morris et al (2006) suggested four theoretical mechanisms for VCD:
- Laryngeal hyper-responsiveness;
- An altered autonomic balance;
- Direct stimulation of sensory nerve endings in the upper or lower respiratory tract;
However, none of these have been robustly investigated and no consensus has been agreed.
Signs and symptoms
VCD is most commonly mistaken for asthma. Morris and Christopher (2010), who reviewed 288 articles on the condition, identified dyspnoea as the predominant symptom during VCD episodes, with others including wheeze, cough and chest tightness (Box 1).
Box 1. Signs and symptoms of vocal cord dysfunction
- Chest tightness
- Throat tightness
- Changes in voice
Source: Morris and Christopher (2010)
VCD “attacks” are usually episodic, acute, and have an abrupt onset. Patients are also likely to have increased medical use, with recurrent emergency visits or hospitalisations (Mikita and Parker, 2006).
Patients do not usually respond to increased doses of asthma medication but if they do the effects are short-lived. If they are on asthma medication, dosage levels are typically high and do not usually correspond with pulmonary function test results or respiratory chest investigations. Many people with VCD have, therefore, been unsuccessfully treated for years, with escalating dosages of asthma medication resulting in a “refractory asthma” label.
The symptoms of VCD typically resolve over a few hours and patients are often asymptomatic between episodes. This can make diagnosis challenging; if patients are investigated during an asymptomatic period, test result data will most likely be normal. Morris and Christopher (2010) described three main criteria for diagnosing VCD:
- Clinical symptoms and patient history;
- Laryngoscopic evidence of abnormal vocal cord movement during breathing;
- Spirometry findings of an abnormal flow volume loop (usually the inspiratory loop) or lack of airway hyperactivity.
Clinical symptoms and laryngoscopic findings are essential to diagnosing VCD but spirometry is not an independent confirmation of VCD and normal flow volume loops can be produced. Despite this, spirometry data can be a good indicator to raise suspicion, especially during a routine asthma review.
The potential irregularity and inconsistency of VCD attacks mean a detailed case history is essential to diagnosing the condition. Clinicians should discuss the following with patients:
- Onset of symptoms;
- Attack episodes;
- Psychological aspects;
- Voice difficulties;
- Laryngeal sensory symptoms, such as aching or a tickling in the throat.
Patients with VCD will typically have had numerous investigations and multiple drug therapy trials, and may have adopted a chronic disease behaviour pattern as a result. When taking a verbal history, health professionals should ask patients to point to where they “feel” the airway obstruction is and whether it is predominantly an inspiratory or expiratory breathing restriction. If the patient points to the upper chest or laryngeal region, this is indicative of VCD – as is a predominantly inspiratory breathing restriction. However, it is still difficult to determine whether patients with VCD also have underlying reactive airways disease or if underlying asthma is a potential trigger for VCD (Morris and Christopher, 2010).
Laryngoscopy during a symptomatic attack is considered the gold standard for VCD diagnosis. It facilitates direct visualisation of the vocal cords during respiration and allows the clinician to assess vocal cord movements and laryngeal musculature presentations.
Christopher et al (1983) described the classic finding for VCD as inspiratory vocal cord closure of the anterior two-thirds of the vocal cords, with the formation of a posterior diamond-shaped chink.
Spirometry is a useful diagnostic tool in clinical practice to help differentiate between a true asthma diagnosis and a possible diagnosis of VCD. If a patient has not responded to numerous asthma medications and a step-up medical management approach is about to be implemented, a detailed review of spirometry can be important.
Spirometry data with a FEV1/FVC ratio does not indicate poor asthma control, meaning VCD may be part of the patient’s presentation. In patients who are symptomatic, flow volume loops can be used to aid diagnosis; these patients with VCD will usually produce a flattened inspiratory flow volume loop, indicating an extrathoracic obstruction, and then a normal loop once the VCD episode has passed (Sterner et al, 2009). However, the limited data available suggests only a quarter of patients with VCD who are asymptomatic produce baseline flattened inspiratory flow volume loops. Baseline normal flow volume loops should therefore not be used to exclude a diagnosis of VCD in patients who are asymptomatic (Perkner et al, 1998).
It is essential that patients continue to be treated in line with their previous asthma or respiratory condition until a diagnosis of VCD is confirmed. Once diagnosed, speech and language therapy (SALT) has been identified as the cornerstone for its treatment and management (Christopher, 2006). This includes:
- Education, including psychological support if required;
- Reducing tension in the head, neck and vocal tract;
- Increased self-awareness of a relaxed diaphragmatic breathing cycle;
- Laryngeal airway control.
Therapeutic techniques can often prevent VCD episodes, or give patients the confidence to reduce or manage them. Once these techniques are established, medications can be reviewed and unnecessary interventions ceased.
In acute VCD episodes, where a patient has had no SALT or struggles to apply techniques with success, heliox can be administered via a rebreathable mask. Heliox is a helium-oxygen mixture; the low density of the gas mixture allows easy movement of air through the closed vocal cords (Goldman and Meurs, 1991). In addition to SALT intervention, it is important to treat comorbidities, such as rhinitis and gastroesophageal reflux.
One of the main issues for VCD management is poor awareness of the condition. Lancashire Teaching Hospital’s airways service is the UK’s first dedicated multidisciplinary clinic to treat VCD and complex breathlessness management. A survey carried out by the service in 2010, looked at knowledge and understanding of VCD among health professionals. Questionnaires were sent to consultants in otolaryngology and respiratory medicine, SALT therapists, nurses and primary care physicians at all trusts in Lancashire and Greater Manchester. The survey results showed a clear lack of awareness and knowledge of VCD among the majority of health professionals, with 83% saying they either had not heard of VCD, or knew little about it (Box 2).
Box 2. Staff knowledge of vocal cord dysfunction
83% of staff who completed a questionnaire had not heard of, or knew little about vocal cord dysfunction (VCD)
80% of ear, nose and throat consultants said they were confident in managing VCD
60% of respiratory consultants said they were confident in managing VCD
None of the other staff groups who completed the survey expressed confidence about managing VCD
73% of nurses felt they knew little about VCD
15% of nurses had never heard of VCD
80% of speech and language therapists felt they knew little about treatment options, despite speech and language therapy being identified as the gold standard treatment for VCD
Results of a survey carried out by Lancashire Teaching Hospital’s airways service in 2010
Although the data is limited due to the small numbers involved, it suggests a trend towards inaccurate identification of patients with VCD, and a lack of awareness for successful management once suspicion is raised by a clinician. However, specialist tertiary centres are now emerging and awareness is increasing.
Haines et al (2010) reviewed all referrals to our airways service between May 2006 and December 2009; around two-thirds were women and the average age was 52 years. The 202 completed data sets analysed revealed:
- 81% had a confirmed diagnosis of VCD;
- 47% had an additional diagnosis of asthma;
- Of the 140 patients offered SALT after diagnosis, 86% complied with therapy and were seen for around four sessions;
- 59% met treatment goals and were discharged;
- 13% were non-concordant;
- 7% had onward referral;
- 21% were reviewed long term, often due to complexities with dual disease processes.
This data adds further weight to the importance of accurate assessment, diagnosis and treatment for patients with VCD. With increased knowledge, treatment centres will become more widespread and consideration of the condition more routine.
VCD is an important differential diagnosis in asthma and complex breathlessness management. It can coexist with asthma, which can make diagnosis and treatment challenging. If VCD is suspected, the patient should be referred to a specialist centre to ensure accurate intervention and prevent the escalation of unnecessary medical therapies.
American Thoracic Society (2009) What is Vocal Cord Dysfunction? ATS: New York, NY.
Carding P (2000) Paradoxical vocal cord movement: a rare condition that is likely misdiagnosed and mistreated. Clinical Otolaryngology; 25: 241-243.
Christopher K (2006) Understanding vocal cord dysfunction: a step in the right direction with a long road ahead. Chest; 129, 842–843.
Christopher KL et al (1983) Vocal cord dysfunction presenting as asthma. New England Journal of Medicine; 308: 1566-1570.
Goldman J, Meurs M (1991) Vocal cord dysfunction and wheezing. Thorax; 46: 401-404.
Haines J et al (2010) Assessment and treatment of vocal cord dysfunction in the airways clinic. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine; 181: A2559.
Mikita J, Parker P (2006) High levels of medical utilization by ambulatory patients with vocal cord dysfunction as compared to age and gender matched asthmatics. Chest; 129: 4, 905-908.
Morris MJ et al (2006) Vocal cord dysfunction: etiologies and treatment. Clinical Pulmonary Medicine; 13: 2, 73-86.
Morris MJ, Christopher KL (2010) Diagnostic criteria for the classification of vocal cord dysfunction. Chest; 138: 1213-1223.
Newman KB, Dubester SN (1994) Vocal cord dysfunction: a masquerader of asthma. Seminars
in Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine; 15: 161-167.
Perkner JJ et al (1998) Irritant associated vocal cord dysfunction. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine; 40: 2, 136-143.
Sterner JB et al (2009) Inspiratory flow-volume curve evaluation for detecting upper airway disease. Respiratory Care; 54: 4, 461-466.