A pathologist has confirmed that the human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine did not cause the death of Natalie Morton, the schoolgirl from Coventry.
Early media speculation suggested the anti-cancer jab could be responsible, but a post-mortem has found that she died from a large malignant tumour of the heart and lungs.
Dr Caron Grainger, joint director of public health for NHS Coventry and Coventry City Council, said, “The pathologist has confirmed today at the opening of the inquest into the death of Natalie Morton that she died from a large malignant tumour of unknown origin in the heart and lungs. There is no indication that the HPV vaccine, which she had received shortly before her death, was a contributing factor to the death, which could have arisen at any point”.
“We hope that this news will reassure parents that the vaccine is safe and that they should continue to encourage their daughters to be protected against cervical cancer. The HPV vaccination programme will continue as planned in the city from Monday.”
Why was a link made between the HPV vaccine and the girl’s death?
No link should ever have been made. However, the girl died on the same day as receiving her vaccination and this led to associations being drawn between the jab and her death.
This happens largely through misinterpretation of probabilities. Unfortunately, young people do die suddenly of natural causes. Although such events are rare, they are statistically much more common than adverse reactions to routine medical treatments.
Do people ever have severe adverse reactions to vaccinations?
They do but, again, it is much less common than many people think.
In very rare cases, it is possible for someone who is vaccinated to experience an allergic reaction, known as an anaphylactic reaction. These are extraordinarily rare, with a recent study showing that only one anaphylactic reaction is reported in about a million immunisations.
Moreover, most anaphylactic reactions to vaccines do not result in death. According to data from the Office for National Statistics, there has not been a single recorded death due to anaphylactic shock following a vaccination for at least 10 years. This covers all recorded incidents between 1997 and 2007, the last year for which data are available.
What are the benefits of the HPV jab?
It’s been calculated that the UK HPV vaccination programme will ultimately save 400 lives a year. Around 3,000 women a year are currently diagnosed with cervical cancer, and the disease kills more than 1,000 women a year in the UK.
Half of all sexually active women will be infected by a strain of HPV in their lifetime. These infections are responsible for causing more than 99% of cervical cancer cases and a range of other cancers.
The HPV vaccine protects against two types of HPV: strains 16 and 18. Together these cause around 70% of cervical cancers.
Have any side effects been reported?
Yes, all drugs have some side effects and the HPV vaccine is no different.
Very common side effects include:
- pain or discomfort at the injection site,
- redness or swelling at the injection site,
- aching muscles, muscle tenderness or weakness (not caused by exercise), and
Common side effects include:
- gastrointestinal symptoms including nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and abdominal pain,
- itching, red skin rash, hives (urticaria),
- joint pain, and
- fever (≥38°C).
Uncommon side effects (occurring in less than one per 100 but more than one per 1,000 doses of vaccine):
- upper respiratory tract infection (infection of the nose, throat or trachea),
- dizziness, and
- other injection site reactions such as hard lump, tingling or numbness.
For more on the vaccine’s known side effects go to Health A-Z: side effects.
Does the vaccine have a good safety record?
The vaccine’s safety record is excellent and it has passed the rigorous safety tests needed for it to be used in the UK and other European countries.
It underwent safety testing as part of the licensing process, with over 70,000 doses used in clinical trials here before a licence was granted (it’s now licensed in more than 90 other countries).
In total, more than 1.4 million doses of the vaccine have since been given in Britain, and millions more worldwide.
Who should have the vaccine?
The HPV vaccine is being offered to all girls aged 12-13 as part of a national vaccination programme that aims to cut deaths and serious illness from cervical cancer. The vaccination programme began in September 2008. By 2011, all girls under 18 in Britain will have been offered the jab. The vaccine is given in three injections over six months. A catch-up programme also started in September 2008 and offers the vaccine to other older girls up to the age of 18.
How does the vaccine work?
Virtually all cases of cervical cancer are caused by a virus called human papilloma virus (HPV), which is passed on during sex (although sexual intercourse isn’t always necessary to pass on the virus).
The vaccine, Cervarix, which is used in the NHS national programme protects against two types of HPV, strains 16 and 18, which together cause around 70% of cervical cancers.
What is HPV?
HPV is a virus that infects the deepest layer of the skin or genital surfaces. There are over 100 different types of HPV, 13 of which are known to cause cervical cancer. The others are harmless or cause genital warts. The virus is transmitted through sexual contact and is very common, with over half of all women becoming infected at some point in their lifetime.
How does HPV cause cancer?
Most HPV infections clear up by themselves, but in some people the infection can last a long time.
HPV infects the cells of the surface of the cervix (the neck of the womb), where it can stay for many years without anyone knowing.
HPV can damage these cells, leading to changes in their appearance. Over time, these changes can develop into cervical cancer.
Will the cervical cancer programme be suspended?
No. There are no plans to suspend the vaccination programme.
As with any vaccine, Cervarix is associated with side effects, but overall this is a well tested vaccine that’s been introduced to tackle a serious health problem.
The MHRA has reviewed all reported side effects related to Cervarix and concluded there is no evidence to suggest that the vaccine carries any long-term side effects.
The independent Expert Advisory Group of the Commission on Human Medicines has reviewed the data and endorses the MHRA’s view that no new or serious risks have been identified and the balance of risks and benefits remains overwhelmingly favourable.
Should I let my daughter have the cervical cancer jab?
Yes. The established risks of getting cervical cancer are far, far greater than any risk from the HPV vaccine.