Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

Care homes should be viewed as positive placements for students and not as 'last resort'


Care homes are being viewed “as a last resort” for nursing students when no other placements can be found, according to managers, who say the setting should be valued more highly by educators.

They argue that universities should do more to recognise and promote the sector as a stimulating and rewarding place to work.

“Care home nursing is a much misunderstood part of the nursing family”

Deborah Sturdy

This is one finding from a year-long project designed to make the most of the “untapped expertise” of nurses working in care homes and boost the image of care home nursing.

The Teaching Care Home pilot was funded by the Department for Health and led by Care England, which represents independent care services.

It involved five care homes embarking on a range of nurse-led projects aimed at improving the learning environment for staff, as well as nursing students and others on practice placements.

Key staff from each home received bespoke training from the Foundation of Nursing Studies, which also consulted staff, service providers, residents, universities, commissioners and others in order to draw up a draft vision for a “teaching care home”.

Meanwhile, the year-long project has also seen Manchester Metropolitan University devise a new Education and Development Framework for Care Home Nurses.

Findings from the pilot have been compiled in a series of reports put together by the International Longevity Centre UK and published today.#

As part of the project, university researchers interviewed managers, registered nurses and care workers at each site.

“The registered nurses who were interviewed often spoke positively about the person-centredness of their work,” said one report on the themes that emerged from the interviews.

“This was contrasted with nursing in the NHS,” it said. “In a care home setting, some of these nurses felt they had the opportunity in their job to form meaningful bonds with both residents and their families.”

However, nurses also highlighted the need for more continuous professional development to help them develop their own skills and achieve career goals, such as becoming prescribers or managers.

“Both nurses and carers have a vital part to play in the professional nursing agenda”

Martin Green

Many “spoke passionately about the existing talent in care homes” and the need to ensure all staff had training and career paths to help them realise their potential, it said.

“The importance of leadership and good management was also highlighted in retaining talented nurses in the sector,” stated the report.

Care home managers added that lack of financial resources was the main thing getting in the way of providing training opportunities for staff.

They also said negative views of care home nursing held by universities and others were a barrier to attracting new nurses to the sector.

All managers interviewed said they were interested in hosting student nurses on placements and three of the care homes already did so.

However, managers also expressed their frustration “at the type of student nurse they were sent”.

One said they were often sent mental health nurses rather than general nurses.

“One manager was frustrated that students were sent to the home as a last resort because they can’t find a placement elsewhere,” said the report.


Care homes should be viewed as positive placements for students

Berwick Grange, Harrogate

“This made the manager feel the home is seen as second class and they wondered if the students felt this too. The manager also felt the staff at the university did not appreciate the reality of care home nursing,” it said.

One suggested those responsible for assigning student nurses did not fully appreciate the complexity of care home nursing and that it could give nursing students “important experience in skills such as leadership, budget management complex clinical care, decision making and responsibility”.

Managers said care home nursing was a specialism requiring skills that often made it “more challenging than hospital nursing”.

“If you want to learn about staff leadership, I’ve got 150 staff that need leading,” said one. “If you want to learn about managing a budget and appropriately staffing units according to a budget, I’ve got £3.2m coming in and out. If you want to learn about decisions you make and how they would directly affect an individual’s care, I’ve got individuals here with very challenging nursing needs.”

In order to secure more student placements in care homes, they were keen for university placement teams to visit homes and “see what working in a busy, good care home is like as a nurse”.

As well as identifying overarching themes, the project involved specific pieces of work.

Barchester Healthcare

Care homes should be viewed as positive placements for students

Chester Court, Bedlington

Nurses and other staff who took part reported improved teamwork, communication and confidence and said they had been inspired to look for new ways to improve care.

One of the pilot sites – Berwick Grange in Harrogate – developed a career route for care workers from overseas who were nurses in their home countries to become registered nurses in the UK.

This included a tailored course to improve spoken and written English. Seven care workers are about the start the programme.

The home, which is run by care provider MHA, also strengthened links with Harrogate College and took three health and social care students on placement.

According to the evaluation, “staff reported a change in atmosphere and staff morale” at the home and one care worker is now applying to do a nursing degree as a result of the project.

Other projects explored particular aspects of care. Staff at Chester Court in Bedlington looked at ways to improve nutrition and develop an approach that was more responsive to the needs and wishes of residents.

It included introducing more flexible mealtimes and a cold menu available at any time of day.

Meanwhile, staff with expertise in dementia provided training for others on the challenges of ensuring residents with the condition were properly nourished. Staff reported improved weight gain in residents.

martin green

martin green

Martin Green

The home, which is run by Barchester Healthcare, also saw improved staff morale after introducing a points scheme to reward those “who go the extra mile”.

Professor Martin Green, chief executive of Care England, said the pilot showed care homes had a key role to play in training and developing an integrated workforce.

“These pilots demonstrate that the care sector is a crucial part of the health and social care landscape, and both nurses and carers have a vital part to play in the professional nursing agenda,” he said.

“This initiative has fostered strong partnerships and goes some way to developing a sustainable workforce that takes pride in high quality, joined-up care,” said Professor Green.

One of the goals of the project was to “improve the image and visibility” of care home nursing.

deborah sturdy

deborah sturdy

Deborah Sturdy

Evaluators said it is “too early to judge” whether this objective had been a success and ongoing work would be “crucial” to spreading the word among undergraduate nurses.

Professor Deborah Sturdy, director of health and wellbeing at Royal Hospital Chelsea and nursing advisor to Care England, said it was important to challenge misconceptions about care home nursing.

“Care home nursing is a much misunderstood part of the nursing family that requires a plethora of skills not often recognised by NHS colleagues,” she said.

“Without expert nurses in care homes many older people, or those with learning disabilities, do not receive the care that they need and deserve,” she added.

The pilot sites are as follows:

  1. Millbrook Lodge, Orders of St John Care Trust in Gloucestershire
  2. Rose Court, HC-One in Bury
  3. Berwick Grange, MHA in Harrogate
  4. Lady Sarah Cohen House, Jewish Care, in Barnet
  5. Chester Court, Barchester in Bedlington

Readers' comments (10)

  • I was a student who missed having a nursing home placement, but many did in our first year. They were he reason many dropped out, the care assistants seemed to have a hatred for student nurses and the atmospheres were terrible. Thy were not inducive environments for learning and many found them quite horrendous.

    It's a shame that they were such bad experiences, but there does appear to be a 'chip on shoulder attitude' which I also experienced doing bank in a nursing hom (of which I had to raise concerns to the CQC for absolutely abhorrent care attitudes and practices!)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It is the advent of the CQC which has encouraged this improvement , for years Nursing Homes were under control of the Local Area Health Authorities which in general treated the task of Registration and inspection very differently and in many areas it was down to the whims of the Inspection officers who in most cases had never even worked in Care Homes and had no idea of what the Public required of them.
    Customer satisfaction etc were concepts which were never considered,
    Now is the time that Nurses working in Nursing Homes need to stand up and be counted,and be proud of what they do, there are millions of satisfied clients out there whom we know would be more than willing to give glowing testimonials if they had been asked in the past.
    You have to blow your own trumpet or the knockers will grind you down.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • ANONYMOUS 25 APRIL, 2017 4:49 PM

    You forget to mention the attitude of the Nurse in Charge ,surely you should have related any problems to this person. I must say as a student you seem to have an unusual attitude towards teamwork.
    By the way constructive criticism is always welcome as long as it is based on real experiance and understanding.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I wouldn't put our cat in one let alone a fellow human being.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Care homes are the last place on earth to put students into.
    Care assistants hate the trained staff & would eat students alive

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree possibly only select homes should be chosen however the fact of the matter is that care homes are here to stay.As the population gets older and dementia increases the profession needs to reconsider nursing in care homes. We cannot ignore this sector but am forced to agree that it could be a harsh environments for young students.
    Possibly the bigger picture is for mandatory training for carers.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It saddens me that all nursing homes are tarred with the same brush. The one I lead welcomes students and I have had positive feed back from Tutors and students alike. It can be a fun and rewarding place to work. I came from a background in District Nursing but love my current post.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am so saddened by some of these comments.
    As a former nursing home Matron/Manager in 2 large nursing homes (consecutively) and as a Nurse Educator, I had previously been involved as a Senior Nurse Manager in the NHS working on, amongst other things, management of change. Both of these homes had only been open for about 18 months and neither had functioned well. It was obvious that there was a lack of education on all levels. Bringing in team meetings and setting up education across the board for all staff from housekeeping to senior nurses brought amazing change. To cut a long story short working with 2 universities enabled us to eventually offer well respected "Return to Practice", "Overseas Nurses induction and Registration" and Student Nurse Training.My staff undertook training and enjoyed working as mentors We gave everyone a really good insight into holistic nursing care, teaching them to see the patient as a whole including their family where available. Regular meetings with other Nursing Home and Hospital Managers within the Independent Sector enabled exchange of good practice.
    Having said all of this I went to many hospitals to assess potential patients and was met at times with outright hostility by nurses, including a first year Staff Nurse asking me if I knew what the different drugs were that the patient was on, including a laxative!!
    Nursing homes are closing all over the country, community staff, particularly home carers are in short supply, social services are facing huge cuts and hospitals have so many delayed discharges that there must be good relationships and respect for the sake of all patients.
    Wherever we all work we ALL do a great job,can have so much job satisfaction and elderly care is so rewarding.
    I know that I was lucky to be able to convince 2 separate employers of the need for all of this and it was very hard at times trying to argue the case at monthly budget and accounts meetings but persuading them both that it would pay in the long term did eventually succeed!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • VILLAGEGIRL 1 MAY, 2017 6:57 PM

    You make me proud to be working in Care Homes.
    It is sad to hear comments such as those coming from bigots such as SHAMEONYOU perhaps you could refer him /her to to other participants in the schemes that you implemented so that they could get a broader picture for comparisons than Cats Homes

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Homes giving holistic care by well trained staff of all types are places that we need more of; homes where ignorance and bullying pervade exist.

    There is too much variation in the quality of care nationwide and too little respect for those doing a decent job. Care can be shockingly poor or pretty wonderful.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.