Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

Case highlights ‘poor weekend care’ at Welsh hospital

  • 2 Comments

A public service watchdog has recommended a review of escalation procedures and training for nursing staff at a Welsh hospital, in the wake of a case involving an “appalling lack of weekend care.

A patient at a South Wales hospital died following a “complete lack of medical staff involvement” in his care over a weekend, according to an investigation by the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales. He said the case reinforced a need for a national review of out-of-hours care at the “earliest opportunity”.

“This case raises several concerns about the quality of patient care over a weekend”

Nick Bennett

The ombudsman’s report, published today, said that the patient – anonymised as Mr Y– was admitted to the Royal Gwent Hospital in Newport on a Thursday with constipation and the plan was to discharge him on the Friday as soon as he had opened his bowels.

However, due to an increase in his blood glucose levels he was kept in hospital over the weekend, despite there being a care package in place for him at home, the ombudsman found.

The report noted that Mr Y’s blood glucose levels continued to fluctuate and he had difficulty swallowing with possible aspiration.

However, nursing staff failed to inform the medical team so Mr Y was not medically reviewed at all on the Saturday, said the report.

In addition, the ombudsman highlighted that he was not assessed by the speech and language therapist, because the service “does not cover weekends”.

Then, on Sunday, Mr Y subsequently developed pneumonia. The clinician on duty was informed but failed to respond and nursing staff did not escalate their concerns to senior staff, the report said.

In fact, it was not until six hours later that a junior doctor finally reviewed Mr Y’s condition, which seriously delayed the administering of potentially lifesaving antibiotics, said the ombudsman.

“There is a need for a review of out-of-hours care at the earliest opportunity”

Nick Bennett

His “condition continued to deteriorate” and the patient “sadly died in the early hours of Monday”, the report stated.

Nick Bennett, public services ombudsman for Wales, said: “This case raises several concerns about the quality of patient care over a weekend.

“Whilst Aneurin Bevan Health Board claims that earlier medical review would not have made any difference to the tragic outcome for Mr Y and his family, I cannot be certain of that,” he said.

“I have made several recommendations to the health board including a payment of £2,000 to Mrs X for the distress caused by her father’s care, a review of its escalation procedures and training for nursing staff,” he said.

Mr Bennett added that he had previously upheld complaints against the Royal Gwent that raised “similar issues” and said that to “see repetition of these issues is troubling”.

Public Services Ombudsman for Wales

Case highlights ‘poor weekend care’ at Welsh hospital

Nick Bennett

He noted that he had published a thematic report – titled Out of hours: Time to care – earlier this year, which highlighted “my concerns about out-of-hours care in Wales”.

“This case only emphasises those concerns, and that there is a need for a review of out-of-hours care at the earliest opportunity,” he said.

In response, Aneurin Bevan Health Board said it accepted the report’s findings and that it was “finalising a detailed action plan”, which would set out the further actions that will be undertaken to meet the recommendations outlined in the report.

Such actions included “reminding our staff of appropriate processes and escalation procedures and addressing any further training needs among nursing staff”.

The implementation of the actions will be “monitored and shared” with the Welsh Government, said a statement from the health board.

It added: “We are writing to the family of Mr Y to unreservedly apologise for the failings identified in the ombudsman’s report.”

  • 2 Comments

Readers' comments (2)

  • OMG - I can not believe what I have read ... Why blame the 'out of hours' when the NURSES were clearly to blame for this gentleman's death by:
    1. Failed to inform the medical team.
    2. Failed to escalate concerns to senior person (whoever they might have been) when medical staff DNA Mr Y (no reason given to lack of medical response).
    If Medics and Consultants are to be on duty during the weekends, then surely this MUST apply to the speech and language therapist (SALT)when they will be available for patients who have difficulty swallowing with possible aspiration, it would appear they too are as essential part of patient care - so get them into work at weekends.

    If not already undertaken - All nursing staff must be investigated, especially in light of Nick Bennett stating - that he had previously upheld complaints against the Royal Gwent that raised “similar issues” and said that to “see repetition of these issues is troubling”.
    Actions included “reminding our staff of appropriate processes and escalation procedures and addressing any further training needs among nursing staff” - yet again we here the same old course of actions to be undertaken, but why are staff not NOT aware of these processes and procedures and NEED further training .... always AFTER they have been exposed !!!

    former RGN - CAVUHB

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ellen
    could it be that the nurses are complacent to the point of inertia because of poor senior management? That must have something to do with it since both nursing and medical staff were negligent, again!

    Like doctors and nurses, senior NHS managers MUST be regulated and checked. This is so overdue. Jeremy Hunt -are you listening??

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.