Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

Leaders clash over healthcare in election TV debate


The leaders of the three main parties made history last night as they crossed swords in the first ever televised prime ministerial general election debate.


When the debate turned to the NHS, the leaders were quizzed on their visions for the future of the healthcare system - particularly care for the elderly.

Gordon Brown said he wanted to help more people remain in their own homes rather than having to move to care or nursing homes.

He also set out a number of “personal guarantees” for patients, including that they could see a cancer specialist within two weeks, get diagnostic tests within one week, get an operation within 18 weeks and see a GP at weekends and in the evenings.

“I want people to know that public services are personal to people’s needs, and that’s why we need to give these guarantees to individual patients,” the prime minister said.

David Cameron thanked the nurse who had asked the question and spoke of his experiences with the NHS - describing it as a “wonderful, wonderful thing”.

Referring to his son Ivan, who died after battling illness, he said: “What it did for my family and my son I will never forget.

“I went from hospital to hospital, A&Es in the middle of the night, sleeping in different wards and different places - and the dedication and the vocation and the love that you get from people who work in the NHS makes me incredibly proud of this country.”

He said the Tories had made an “exception” of the NHS by pledging to increase spending in real terms, but also said he wanted to make sure “we improve it, we expand it, we develop it, we make sure that it’s got more choice and more control for the patient”.

Mr Cameron also said he wanted to make cancer drugs available to people who need them.

Nick Clegg said it was easy to say how much everybody needed and relied on the NHS, but difficult to say how it would be protected when money is tight.

Arguing that the priorities at the moment “are all wrong”, the Lib Dem leader said 5,000 managers had been recruited in the last year while A&E and maternity wards were being closed.

“What is going on? We are closing A&E departments and maternity wards, and wasting money on computer systems and bureaucracy,” he said.

“I want to turn that on its head so we can protect the NHS that we all rely on.”

Mr Brown and Mr Cameron argued over why the Tories did not back Labour’s guarantees on cancer and being able to see GPs in the evening and weekends.

But the Tory leader said the UK’s death rate from cancer was worse than Bulgaria’s despite all Mr Brown’s investment, and claimed Labour’s National Insurance rise would take £200m out of the NHS which could be better spent on a cancer drugs fund.

Mr Clegg said it was a “phoney debate” and appealed for a “bit of honesty” as he set out plans to cut NHS bureaucracy and invest the money on the front line.

“People know that money is tight,” he said.

“People know that you can’t promise something for nothing.”


Readers' comments (2)

  • Gordon Brown came off particularly badly in this debate in my opinion. His policies on health are pretty much more of the same anyway, top heavy service, money poured into the wrong areas, and his "personal guarantees” for patients, including that they could see a cancer specialist within two weeks, get diagnostic tests within one week, get an operation within 18 weeks and see a GP at weekends and in the evenings, again is just more of the same. I notice he said nothing about the staff who are supposed to carry out all these grandiose schemes. We are already stretched too thin, with too few staff numbers and too little pay to renumerate us for the skill level/work that we do. Labour has failed and he offered nothing new.

    Cameron was better, but not by much, his policies are actually pretty similar to Labours, but I did like his notion to get Cancer drugs for the patients that need them, if that means giving NICE a slap and telling them to give the best drugs to those that need them, then that is a great idea in my book.

    Nick Clegg focused on the waste in the NHS such as the computter system and the top heavy beauracracy, middle management and trust execs, which in my opinion made him come out on top in this debate. The Health policies of the Lib Dems are quite good too, whilst not as good as some of the minor parties such as UKIP, they still offer some pretty good policies that will affect Nurses in a good way.

    I just wish UKIP, the Greens and the other UK 'minor' parties had been given a voice alongside them so that they could have argued their policies on Health too.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • No change from any one of the them. They're still insistant that state commisioning and provision is the only way forward.

    Ladies and gentleman I give you whatever we decide we can afford whenever we've lost all your cash. Would you like some MRSA with that while your at it?

    Thanks guy's, I'll make sure my standing order to my PMI is working.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.

Related Jobs