Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

One in four nurses would strike as job fears increase

  • 66 Comments

Nurses have become so concerned about their job security and working conditions that more than a quarter say they would go on strike, Nursing Times’ largest ever survey has found.

Out of more than 5,000 respondents, 26 per cent would consider striking if they were unhappy with their working conditions.

I don’t think nursing has a history of taking industrial action. But people are incredibly worried about their jobs

Only 15 per cent would not consider any industrial action. The majority - 67 per cent - said they would work to rule by, for example, leaving work the minute their shift ended or breaks started.

There has never been a national all-out nursing strike in England, but Nursing Times’ survey demonstrates the extent of nurses’ insecurities and determination to protect jobs and services amid plans for a massive NHS shake-up and efforts to save £20bn.

Asked to rank a series of statements according to the extent they agreed or disagreed, the largest proportion -38 per cent - agreed most strongly with the statement “I feel insecure in my job - I feel scared I will be laid off”.

In contrast, the largest proportion to disagree strongly were the 50 per cent who said they could not sign up to the statement “I feel optimistic about the future of nursing in the NHS”.

Ealing and Harrow provider services nurse consultant Linda Nazarko said the scale of change planned for the NHS had left nurses “very fearful”.

Introducing Nursing Times Learning

Online training units, written and reviewed by experts. Earn two hours’ CPD and a personalised certificate for your portfolio.

Subscribers get five FREE learning units and non-subscribers can access each learning unit for £10 + VAT.

Click on the topics below to get started:

“I don’t think nursing has a history of taking industrial action. But people are incredibly worried about their jobs,” she said.

The difficulty of organising effective action without compromising patient care was laid bare by the survey.

Mental health and intensive care nurses were most likely to consider going on strike, with 40 per cent and 39 per cent respectively saying they were prepared to do this.

Practice nurses, healthcare assistants and nursing directors were the least likely to say they would take any form of action, including protesting outside working hours.

Overall, approximately half put “industrial action should never affect patient care or services” at the top of a question asking respondents to rank a series of related statements.

However, more than a quarter said the statement they most agreed with was “Industrial action will only work if patient care and services are affected”.

The survey also revealed that while the majority would consider industrial action, 44 per cent were prepared to sacrifice a pay rise to protect their job.

Overall, 70 per cent of respondents said the change most likely to push them towards industrial action was if spending cuts compromised patient care.

Other inflammatory issues were pay cuts - which would lead to 58 per cent taking industrial action - and a worsening of pension terms, which would trigger 53 per cent to take industrial action.

Royal College of Nursing head of employment relations Josie Irwin said: “The findings chimed with what our reps have been telling us. The concern was about jobs and restructuring and your survey has highlighted the fact that pensions are a real point for anxiety.

“When there have been these culls before, there has been so much skill and so much experience lost.

“Clinical nurse specialists seem to have been targeted by the more gung-ho, slash and burn managers. It is so shortsighted because all the research shows their contribution, not just to readmission and patient care, but economically.”

RCN critical care forum chair Rachel Binks said senior nurses had an important role in ensuring staff were kept aware of any changes under discussion.

She said: “We’re the eyes and ears of the hospital for the managers and are in a position to pick up feelings of unrest among the nurses and domestic staff and feed back any questions.”

A DH spokesman said efficiency gains would not result in cuts to clinical posts “unless costs rise without productivity gains”, but nurses may need to work in different trusts or in new roles.

He added: “We are committed to supporting nurses and their clinical colleagues to deliver better, more effective and efficient care.”

As revealed previously in Nursing Times, trusts are already withholding pay increments to nurses with poor sickness absence records or asking staff to consider pay cuts in return for job security.

Last week all 3,000 staff at Liverpool Primary Care Trust were offered options including voluntary redundancy or working part time as part of a savings programme.

Poll

Should nurses go on strike?

View poll results
  • 66 Comments

Readers' comments (66)

  • As an employee of the above named LPCT i feel as reflected less secure about my future than ever. A real sense of downdrading seems to be the PCT way forwards. I like my colleagues have offered years of service to this employer only to find reduced terms for MARS and likewise fears over pensions. With this in mind most of the service i work with have concidered altermative employment so far as outside nursing or the NHS. The future once so clear has become clouded. The treatment of staff, in my opinion, by LPCT or as it is now called Liverpool Community Health makes it hard to believe it managed to pull out of the bag the BEST national PCT. When asked if i would recommend nursing as a career now i tend to say NO. Whilst it certainly has its rewards it terms of actual nursing care it offers no other job security or satisfaction. if asked now would i strike the answer sadly would be a definite YES.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I do not agree that going on strike will achieve job security. Where ever strikes have taken place there seems to have been even greater loss of jobs.
    Demonstrations and working only your contracted hours I feel are the best ways of getting messages across to the government. Problem is some nurses work well above their contracted hours at the moment which gives nhs management the opportunity not to fill vacant posts.
    I remember a nhs strike in the 80's and it brought out the worst in nurses and ancilliary staff. How can you strike without some knock on effect to patients, waiting lists, operations etc. Remember it could be you wanting a hospital bed!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I believe it is time for nurse to band together. Its not just about job security, its about ensuring nurses have a voice [finally] within the NHS family and patient services are secure. Our needs as professionals need to be maintained. Sometimes the hard things affecting patients services etc in the short term is the right thing to be done for furture change and benifit of patient care. The BMA would support their Drs no mater what! it is about time that the RCN or such like did the same.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just a quarter? One in four? I am seriously, seriously disappointed in that number!

    No wonder the profession is in so dire straits when so few of you out there are willing to fight for it!

    It is slightly heartening to read that 67% at least are willing to work to rule.

    The simple fact is, Nurses NEED TO STRIKE!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I gree to a point that Working to Rule ( and making sure the majority DO work to rule ) can be very effective and crippling without patient compromise...striking should only come further down the track if working to rule failed. As has been said before on numerous occasions Im sure there is NOT ONE NURSE that would really feel comfortable about striking...but it can be done with effect as proven.
    I believe with the survey that the figures are probably higher than 1:4 in reality, as although confidential there would still be a large amount of nurses out there just too scared to voice their opinions, and how many nurses did not complete the survey? What goes through ones mind may not be what they put on the survey.( amazingly! )
    BTW Anon 8:54
    This is not the 80,s....most nurses in Aust/ /Canada and now USA are getting what they want with a strong backup.Appears UK is going backwards and you are all now worried that you will have a job? Disgraceful!
    Get that new nurses union formed

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree With Mike Nurses need to stick together and if strike means that our voice is heard then so be it! something needs to be done and soon. i am nearing the end of my nurse training and yet after 3 years hard slog (dont get me wrong i have loved every second) but i may not be able to get a job and if i do is it going to be secure????????

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Only 5000 replied out of how many nurses in the UK? Doesn't that show the level of disinterest/apathy?
    Working to contract is an extremely effective tool. It is difficult to do and everyone MUST agree and follow the rules. It doesn't take long for the management teams to realize the loss.
    Plan it, cover patient care and you are carrying out your role as per your contract and still acting in a responsible and professional manner.
    Stop complaining and get on and do it!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I would also like to adress this issue of any strike action 'affecting patient safety'. This is the mainstay of the emotional blackmail that is aimed at us and should be stopped.

    Basically the argument is that if we strike, there will be noone there to give care and patients will suffer.

    Fair enough, that is not wrong.

    But the sheer fact that it is not wrong is the exact reason that a strike would work! We are essential, noone else can do what we do!

    I would argue that patients are ALREADY suffering with poor staffing levels, inept management and Nurses not being allowed to care for patients the way they want to, etc etc etc. By allowing this to continue, accepting the status quo and NOT striking, I think we are failing in our duty of care just as much as those in charge would accuse us of doing if we went on strike.

    The fact is we would be fighting for patient safety and care as well. Better working conditions would mean more staff on the wards, that would mean better patient care and better patient safety.

    So patients are ALREADY suffering by us NOT striking, striking would mean they would get better care!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Working to rule i agree works well so long as the rules do not change. in the current climate with the end of PCT and foundation trusts set to rule the land do you think it is not impossible in this new climate for the re writing of job specs as they are permitted to in times of economic change and crisis. if we dare disagree its 90 day notice time or moved under the clearing house system to another job which may be less well paid or dare i say been left vacant for a reason. i would suggest nurses need to band together and in the mean time make sure you understand your employers Operational Change Policy. We all are aware our Unions when it comes to the fight on our behalf are as much use as a chocolate tea pot, but we do pay our subs for something. I say band together and then approach your area union rep. perhaps its time for a new union who like the rest of us are 'fit fpr purpose'.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 25% is pathetic! I'll be one to strike if needs be... what's the worst thet can happen, really?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Show 102050results per page

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.