Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

OPINION

'CCTV in care homes will help protect residents against abuse'

  • 2 Comments

The care system is a vital part of the network designed to protect those most vulnerable in our society, but in many areas it is simply not doing its job.

renu daly

renu daly

Sadly, in some cases there is a failure to protect older, vulnerable people, who are being subjected to neglect and abuse in care.

At Hudgell Solicitors, we have seen a worrying increase in such cases within care home facilities and we believe now is the time to act. Surveillance may be controversial, but the role of CCTV in care homes must now be fully considered by the government.

As part of our Love Our Vulnerable and Elderly campaign, we are backing an e-petition calling for CCTV to be made compulsory in all care homes. It is aiming to secure 10,000 signatures to force a government response; 100,000 signatures could see it make the agenda in Parliament.

The petition was started by Lisa Smith, who decided to take her father Joshua, an 86-year-old army veteran with Alzheimer’s disease, out of care after four years of what she called “a living nightmare”. It also comes as we, as specialists in handling claims of abuse against older people and those who are vulnerable, have been contacted by an increasing number of families who have turned to secret filming, such were their concerns about poor care.

Critics will say that around-the-clock CCTV coverage infringes on a care home resident’s privacy, but research we have conducted has found overwhelming support for cameras from families.

Our campaign is focused on providing love, protection, respect and dignity, and of course we realise that there are many who consider CCTV an intrusion too far. However, surely the least we can do is install CCTV coverage in all communal areas, and have it as an option for residents and families in their own private rooms. As long as there is an option to opt out of surveillance in private areas, then surely there is no reason why it could not be used effectively, and with the approval of all.

Finding the balance between safety and privacy is difficult, but we believe CCTV would not only help prevent abuse from taking place, but could even help care facilities better observe at-risk residents, and offer them protection against malicious allegations. By campaigning for the implementation of surveillance in care homes, we may finally start to tackle this difficult and long-standing problem.

Abuse and neglect is a problem that persists because of the many “unknowns” families are faced with in the care system. Once they leave a facility, it is difficult to know what is truly going on behind closed doors – and while Care Quality Commission inspections help ensure certain standards, the inspection process does have flaws. 

Interestingly, an independent national survey, commissioned by our firm and carried out before we launched our campaign, revealed an increasing openness to CCTV footage being used in care homes, as relatives believed it would help protect their loved ones from abuse and neglect. It found that:

  • 83% of those surveyed would agree to their relative being filmed 24 hours a day – or would go as far as filming secretly if they felt a loved one was not being cared for;
  • 40% would not trust a care home or residential home to provide a safe environment for their loved one.

These figures suggest the time has come to make a change. The aim of our campaign is far from a potential invasion of privacy, or an infringement of human rights – it is to ensure older people and the vulnerable are loved, respected, protected and cared for with dignity at all times. 

Renu Daly is a solicitor at Hudgell Solicitors, specialising in claims of care home abuse and neglect

  • 2 Comments

Readers' comments (2)

  • If 40% of persons would not entrust a Care Home to look after their loved ones then the solution is simple: do not place your loved one in a care home of any description under any circumstances. As a nurse of 19 years years who has worked in > 200 care homes I am appalled at the suggestion that cameras with the specific purpose of spying on staff should be allowed. If there is any doubt about staff then they should not be allowed in the building. I am sure that Ms Daly would welcome the introduction of cameras within solicitor's offices throughout the country to record all private confidential conversations with clients in order to prevent abuse of vulnerable clients and protect solicitors from "malicious allegations"

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To Phililippe

    I wish my view of what goes on in a care home were as simplistic as yours. However experience prevents it.

    The problem is that all the institutions put in place to prevent neglect and abuse from occurring and continuing are insufficient to prevent it or are complicit in its delivery.

    The institutions I refer to are the Local Authority including Safeguarding, the Office of the Public Guardian, the NHS Supervisory Bodies i.e. CCGs and Trusts, the Care Quality Commission, the Court of Protection, the Parliamentary and Health Services Ombudsman and the Police. All seem to be short of staff or staff of sufficient calibre to perform their functions. So neglect and abuse, in bucketfuls keeps happening. It needs to stop.

    Your idea that staff should be prevented from entering the building if there is any doubt about them would facilitate bad employers intent on profit gained through delivering bad care in getting rid of decent staff by inventing false allegations against them without hard evidence. It would also breach employment laws.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.

Related Jobs