This article explores the effectiveness of health checks for people with learning disabilities in identifying unmet health needs.
People with learning disabilities have poorer health than their non-disabled peers and evidence suggests that this is partly because of barriers associated with identifying ill health and ensuring timely access to healthcare services (Michael, 2008).
The Department of Health (2009) recommends that primary care services provide comprehensive annual health checks for people with learning disabilities using local or directly enhanced schemes (tinyurl.com/ DH-enhanced-services). Local authorities should help to identify individuals who would benefit from and would be eligible for enhanced services.
It is recognised that undertaking comprehensive annual health checks will require considerable effort by primary care staff; therefore, the DH advises that primary care services ensure the availability of resources including support from specialist learning disability community teams as appropriate. In addition, learning disability awareness training for mainstream health professionals should be supported.
A systematic review summarised the available evidence for the impact of health checks on the health and wellbeing of people with learning disabilities (Robertson et al, 2011).
A total of 38 publications were identified. These involved checking the health of more than 5,000 people with learning disabilities from a range of countries including a full range of people with learning disabilities.
Three of the studies found were randomised controlled trials, one had a non-randomised matched control group, but the majority were looking at the outcome of clinical interventions. The studies consistently showed that there were unmet health needs in people with learning disabilities presenting for health checks. Despite this positive finding, the authors urge caution as the evidence is mainly from small-scale studies.
However, they conclude that health checks are effective in identifying previously unrecognised health needs, including life-threatening conditions. Future research should consider strategies for optimising the cost-effectiveness or efficiency of health checks.
Box 1. Commentary
Phil Boulter, consultant nurse at Surrey and Borders Partnership Foundation Trust, says:
“In general the outcomes of this review are to be expected. However, the absence of chest conditions is surprising, particularly related to dysphagia. In the recent Improving Health and Lives report (Emerson et al, 2011), chest conditions were found to be a leading cause of death in people with learning disabilities, which supported evidence from the National Patient Safety Agency (2004) report, Understanding the Patient Safety Issues for People with Learning Disabilities.
“Health checks will generate increased referrals and we need to ensure that services, such as community chiropody and auditory, can cope with the increased demands placed on them. However, in the long term, cost benefits are likely through improving quality of life, improving mental and physical health, and therefore supporting people to lead more independent and fulfilling lives.
“Interestingly the study raises - but does not address - who completes the health checks, which may have cost implications depending on which professional undertakes them.
“As we continue to produce evidence and deliver training to primary and secondary care providers, we are beginning to see changes in practice. These relate to an understanding of the health needs of people with learning disabilities, production of accessible information, increased emphasis on consent and best-interest decisions, and reasonable adjustments in response to disability equality duty. However, much still needs to be done to embed these changes throughout the NHS, and we need to ensure that health checks are consistent and of a good quality, and that the findings are translated into active health alliance plans.”
- Adapted from Eyes on Evidence (March 2012), a bulletin produced by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
- Reproduced with permission.
- Carmel Thomason is senior publishing manager, evidence resources, National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
- Click here for a print-friendly PDF of this article
Department of Health (2009) Health Action Planning and Health Facilitation for People with Learning Disabilities: Good Practice Guidance.
Emerson E et al (2011) Health Inequalities & People with Learning Disabilities in the UK: 2011.
National Patient Safety Agency (2004) Understanding the Patient Safety Issues for People with Learning Disabilities.
Robertson J et al (2011) The impact of health checks for people with intellectual disabilities: a systematic review of evidence. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research; 55: 11, 1009-1019.